Papa's Grill

Located in the heart of Columbus, Indiana, Papa’s Grill is a beloved family restaurant and bar & grill that masterfully blends a welcoming atmosphere with a diverse and delicious menu. Whether you’re craving classic American comfort food or looking to unwind with a cold beer, Papa’s Grill has something to satisfy every palate.

The restaurant’s culinary offerings highlight a well-crafted array of dishes that are both hearty and flavorful. Signature items like the Diablo Burger and the Mushroom Swiss Burger pack bold, juicy flavors, while the Byson Burger and Mini Cheeseburgers offer satisfying options for burger lovers of all ages. For those seeking lighter fare, the Salmon Salad and Oriental Chicken Salad deliver fresh, vibrant ingredients topped with perfectly grilled proteins, balanced with crunchy textures and bright dressings that dance on the palate.

Start your meal with Papa’s generous appetizers such as their famous Mozzarella Wedges—crispy, golden breaded cheese paired perfectly with tangy marinara sauce—or the Papa’s Onion Rings, boasting a light, crispy beer-battered coating accompanied by a smoky chipotle ranch dip. For a true comfort food experience, the Meatloaf Dinner and Chopped Steak are masterfully prepared, evoking nostalgic flavors that warm both heart and soul.

The menu also features crowd-pleasing items like the Buffalo Wing Wrap and Grilled Chicken Wrap, which offer a delightful blend of zesty wings or tender chicken wrapped in fresh tortillas. Fans of fried favorites will appreciate the Papa’s Tenderloin Sandwich and the ever-popular Boneless Wing Basket. A must-try that diners rave about are the crispy, flavorful fries and the house-made cheese wedges, which provide the perfect snack or sidekick to any meal.

Beyond the food, Papa’s Grill cultivates an inviting atmosphere that balances casual charm with family-friendly comfort. The seating is ample, offering both bar-height and regular tables, which adds a fun dynamic to the dining experience. According to guests, the space is roomy enough to avoid long waits, even during busy times, and the easy parking and handicap accessibility enhance convenience for all visitors.

While some guests have noted varying experiences with the staff, the majority praise the dedication and attentiveness of servers like Gabby, who are known for their warm hospitality and in-depth menu knowledge. This combination of great food and friendly service makes Papa’s Grill a reliable choice for community dining and visiting food lovers alike.

In sum, Papa’s Grill embodies the spirit of a true neighborhood gem — a place where fresh ingredients, diverse menu options, and a welcoming setting come together to create memorable meals. Whether you’re stopping by for the phenomenal tilapia, craving a smoky burger, or simply looking for a family spot with a laid-back vibe, Papa’s Grill is sure to satisfy both your appetite and your desire for a comfortable, gratifying dining atmosphere.

Contact: 3780 W Jonathan Moore Pike, Columbus, IN 47201 | Phone: +1 812-342-9736